We’re Still Trying To Ban Books?

One of the greatest books I have ever read is “The Diary of Anne Frank”. That book wrecks me. I have nothing but the utmost respect for Anne Frank. When Justin Bieber went to The Anne Frank house and wrote:Truly inspiring to be able to come here. Anne was a great girl. Hopefully she would have been a belieber.” I wanted to rip him apart (more than I normally do). Then the pictures of him shadow boxing and wearing a hoodie and sunglasses in her house surfaced and I wanted him to be waterboarded and tortured.

That’s how much this girl and that book means to me. It means that much to a lot of people. That book is an inside look at the torture that someone experienced during one of the darkest times in our world’s history and it’s told with the purity of a child.

Gail Horalek of Northville, Michigan has declared war on this piece of history. Horalek wants the book banned. ”The problem is the school is giving the seventh graders inappropriate material and not explaining it to the parents.”

Horalek is talking about the unedited definitive edition of the book. At first Horalek said she thought it was “awesome” that her daughter was doing a school project on the book until her daughter told her the  ”graphic passages” were making her “uncomfortable.” Firstly, no 12-year-old is going to use the phrase “graphic passages” and I highly doubt she’d say “uncomfortable”.

This is the passage the mother is objecting to:

“Until I was eleven or twelve, I didn’t realize there was a second set of labia on the inside, since you couldn’t see them. What’s even funnier is that I thought urine came out of the clitoris…When you’re standing up, all you see from the front is hair. Between your legs there are two soft, cushiony things, also covered with hair, which press together when you’re standing, so you can’t see what’s inside. They separate when you sit down and they’re very red and quite fleshy on the inside. In the upper part, between the outer labia, there’s a fold of skin that, on second thought, looks like a kind of blister. That’s the clitoris.”

She is objecting to a 12-year-old reading the word labia, clitoris, and vagina. I do believe I had to watch a “changing bodies” video when I was ten. I knew all of that language earlier than that….you know why? Cause I have a vagina and I explored it like an other young girl. That’s right–girl’s play with their vagina’s. I guarentee that this girl has touched her vagina and is well aware of the two sets of lips, the and the location of the clitoris. I’m sure some of her friends have even had sex or given head at that age. When I was in middle school in MICHIGAN in the mid 90′s two girls age 11 and 12 were pregnant.

Sorry, mom you can’t save your little girl from knowing about her vagina. You also can’t burn books. I thought we got over banning and burning books. I thought we evolved passed that. But I guess Michigan, the state I grew up in, is a little behind in the times.

Horalek is demanding that the school go back to teaching from the older, edited version of the book that doesn’t include the uncomfortable passages. You know what else is really uncomfortable? The fact that a young girl had to hide in her attic to try and escape being murdered for her religion. Know what else is uncomfortable? The way the book abruptly ends because she was found and sent to a concentration camp where she died along with 6 million others.That’s really uncomfortable.

Maybe we should worry about things that are really hurting our children.



You Might Also Like ...

Men in the Movement

PBS ran an amazing miniseries called Makers: Women that Made America. If you didn’t catch it on TV make sure you watch it online. As impressed as I was with the women in the documentary I found myself more impressed by the men by their side.
One woman spoke of how when she was elected to Congress everyone tried swearing in her husband, not her. It got me thinking about how much it must have taken for a man to stand aside in the 1950’s. Everyone knows that men like to give each other a hard time, little insults here and there. I wonder what was said around whiskey and brandy when a man’s wife was elected.

Not all men were worth admiration at the time. In this documentary they spoke of the men in the feminist movement still expecting their girlfriend’s to cook dinner after the protests and in fact the radical feminist movement became mostly women when they got tired of the men in the movement telling them to “shut up” after their speeches.

Still, it’s not easy to take a back seat to a powerful woman. Even in today’s time—how often do we hear that a celebrity couple breaks up because the female becomes more popular than the male? The ego is quite a hard thing to face. As much as I love the women of the feminist movement I’ve got to say I tip my hat to the men that stood next to them and helped them take that step.

So often women are overlooked, behind every great man is a great woman. I’d like to think it goes both ways. As great team is a great team no matter who’s backing who. That’s how a great team and a great couple work—taking turns having each other’s back.



You Might Also Like ...

Women’s History Month…Exists

Everyone in America knows when Black History month is. It’s taught in schools and all major networks run a graphic that says “Happy Black History Month” or “In Honor of Black History Month”. In short, Black History Month gets a ton of air time. It should. It’s important. Did you know there is a Women’s History Month?

I didn’t either. I learned that March is celebrated as Women’s History Month from Twitter, since the 80’s March has been recognized throughout America, Canada and the UK. I had no clue. It’s not taught in schools, no one runs a graphic on NBC it just goes by silently. There’s not even an influx in female programming or documentaries. Nothing is done to recognize this month. It bothers me—but not as much as it should.

I don’t think we should have separate months celebrating “women” I think it should just be part of history. The women’s rights movement is amazing; it’s inspiring and not just for women. Learning about people standing up to injustice and fighting for equal rights is what this country was founded on. It’s part of our collective history so why separate it?

There’s still a long way to go in the women’s rights movement. There’s a lot of ground to cover but I’m very confident we’ll get there. Maybe on the road we’ll all realize that to be equal means to be together as one. I don’t need a month to celebrate the trials and successes of these amazing women. I do it every day.



You Might Also Like ...

Feminism in the Classroom–Folly or Fantasy?

Schools in America are open to a tremendous amount of criticism.  Much of it is even deserved.  However, the increasingly tight control of curriculum based on political correctness is an area that is worthy of conversation.

It’s kind of an open secret in education that we sanitize the hell out of things that don’t portray us in the best light.  The Civil War was fought because those fine, noble northerners found the idea of slavery morally reprehensible (forget the economy).  Lewis Carroll had a fabulous imagination that really resonated with children (redact the pedophilia).  Our involvement in Vietnam was a success (I’m not really sure how we’re able to keep that whopper floating–probably by arguing that we’re not all a bunch of communists–but somehow the myth perpetuates).

Therefore, the idea of facing head-on a subject that will without question raise controversy and–oh, my stars!–make kids think is invigorating.

That Feminism falls under that umbrella, though … I’m not sure how I feel about that.

I recently attended a fantastic training on inquiry-based instruction and assessment in an English Language Arts classroom (a fancy way to say “good English teaching”).  The presenter, who teaches at an inner-city school in New York City, shared lots of great strategies, techniques, and resources.

What stood out the most to me, though, was a unit she shared focused around feminism. It was absolutely mind-blowing … everything from evaluating the degree of impact made by Charlotte Bronte and Jane Austen to analyzing the philosophies of Mary Wollstonecraft to ..

Continue reading



You Might Also Like ...