The ban on women fighting in combat has been lifted. By 2016 women will be allowed in combat on the front lines and a lot of feminists would say “huzzah” this feminist, however, is not. I don’t agree that women should be on the front lines—not because they are women but because there are things that need to happen on the front lines that the female body as a whole cannot do. That is not to say that some women can’t meet the requirements—of course they can. My concern is that those requirements will be lessened in the interest of appearing “equal”.
Hand grenades have to be thrown 15 meters. They have to. If they are not they can kill the person that threw it or anyone around them. I can’t throw 15 meters, I can throw a spiral and I’ve got what’s been called a “cannon” of an arm—but I can’t throw as far as my dude…my physicality isn’t made the same way. Again, some women will be able to throw that far, some woman can bench more than men, so some women are fit but all women are not and to open those flood gates endanger lives.
Apart from the strength and distance requirements there are the mental requirements. I was brought up by a marine. There is a code: unit, corp, God, country. That’s not just a line from a movie that is a real code that they live by. Your unit is more important than your family—it transcends a family—your unit is an extension of yourself and I’m sorry but some men in the military do not respect women. That will probably never change. Even if it did, men of other cultures do not respect women and to see a woman in an infantry would make her a major target. Much like when Prince Harry wasn’t allowed to fight on the front lines because it would put his unit in danger. People would target HIM and therefore his unit would be targeted. A woman in an infantry puts her unit in a spotlight—not what you want during combat.
There is also cohesion in a unit. This goes back to men not respecting women in the military (rent The Invisible War or read my review to see how much respect we get). You are told to protect the person to your left and your right—but if you hate the person on your right you will not protect them, you may put them in danger and that puts the rest of the unit in danger. Furthermore—what if you get a little crush? Now you’re focused on protecting her at all costs and not following orders. It’s too complicated, it’s too risky.
My point is—there is a ripple effect to this that no one wants to talk about because it’s wrong. It’s so wrong! A woman should be allowed to have any job she wants in the military in theory, but in reality it’s dangerous. Until society can wrap their heads around women being “people” and not the “weaker sex” or “made from man” than, in my opinion, it’s far too dangerous to move forward with this. I’d rather my military be focused on the job at hand and not on the elephant in the room aka “the girl in the unit”.
Tag Archives: culture
Afgan Men Are Becoming Unlikely Allies For Feminism

It’s not an easy task being a feminist, and it’s even more difficult to be a man when pushing for womens’ rights. Some would say it’s actually down-right impossible to be a feminist in Afghanistan, and really, how about being a Afghan male who’s pushing for women’s rights? I would bet that most of you would say it never happens, but you would be wrong.
“Part of the problem in Afghanistan is that most women think like men,” said Kabul university student Ferdous Samim, “I don’t have a sister, but I’m sure if I did, and she tried to go outside the house, my mother would be asking where she was going, what she was doing, why she was going out.”
Samim is a member of the male advocacy wing of activist group YoungWomen4Change, and he, along with a small but critical group of male activists, is trying to help Afghan women fight for more national rights to, hopefully, gain a better life.
Unlike other more developed countries, this is not an easy or small task. In parts of the Middle East, women have little to no rights. Even something as simple as walking to the corner store alone is not permitted. Samim says that in the next two decades, he hopes that women should be able to walk in Afghanistan’s streets and markets without experiencing the customary harassment. The sad facts of the Middle East include forced marriage, the idea that rape victims are jailed for committing “forced adultery” … The list goes on and on. Also, woman is more likely to die in childbirth in Afghanistan than anywhere else on earth. This last fact is astounding to me. Forget heading to the market for some fruits and vegetables – women are not even permitted to give birth in hospitals. They must be at home with a midwife, out of the public eye.
One of the main problems is that the men in power are not keen to listen to female activists, so men have played a very important role in keeping the anti-woman movement continuing forward. Ahmad Nader Nadery, who is commissioner of the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission, says that not all hope is lost:
“Once we open the door to the mullahs, we engage them in discussion, we break the ice,then our female trainers come and they also speak. But we start first.”
The idea is that men make the first move and get the people in power’s minds open to listen and then send the women in.
Other looming issues in Afghanistan is that the people are still recovering from the strict ruling under the Taliban. The Taliban had control from 1996-2001, and they marginalized women even further, stripping them of the right to work, study, or move freely within their communities. A practice known as “baad” is when women are given in marriage to settle disputes, which can apparently lead to dangerous and abusive relationships, yet it’s just another illustration of the current problem: men are not considering the impact that their decisions have on their fellow woman.
With regard to families, the abuse that takes place is also hidden because these units are “closed” Nadery explains:
“Families are very closed. Once a woman enters another family, her story will never get out. Most of those elders, those decision makers, don’t know the suffering she goes through.”
Yet hHow can they be expected to understand or make a change if they don’t know? It’s a whole other set of problems for the region.
In addition to his previous comments, Nadery claims that the AIHRC works with elders, runs workshops, and produces documentaries and dramas to illustrate how damaging “baad” and other abusive traditions can be, and the men they target are often shocked by what they learn. However, it still is not easy to change their minds. Nadery, who credits his feminism to being in a family of strong women says, “It is a long process of work with them.” Luckily there are men like Nadery and Samim who are up to the challenge.
You Might Also Like ...
The Life of a Child Bride

It is pretty easy to forget that the the rituals we celebrate in the West are not common place around the world. If one were to state, “I went to a wedding this weekend”, most of us would probably conjure images of teary audience members, open bars, and a general sense of happiness for the couple to wed. Cynthia Gorney’s recent piece on child brides in National Geographic reminds me that our concept of the wedding is not the norm, and that such ceremonies can set entirely different moods in other countries.
Gorney’s piece opens with a description of the pre-wedding scene of a secret late night wedding to take place in India,
“… it was well into the afternoon before the three girl brides in this dry farm settlement in the north of India began to prepare themselves for their sacred vows. They squatted side by side on the dirt, a crowd of village women holding sari cloth around them as a makeshift curtain, and poured soapy water from a metal pan over their heads. Two of the brides, the sisters Radha and Gora, were 15 and 13, old enough to understand what was happening. The third, their niece Rajani, was 5. She wore a pink T-shirt with a butterfly design on the shoulder. A grown-up helped her pull it off to bathe.”
You Might Also Like ...
Is Music Better Than Sex Now, Too?

Seems to me with the bombardment of studies that are being released which suggest ‘factor x is better than sex,’ perhaps scientists (or the journalists writing the articles) just want us to stop having sex. Or perhaps those who aren’t having sex are just dying for another alternative.
In the ever growing list of things that have been deemed ‘better than sex,’ music has thrown its hat in the ring. Following the likes of housework, the internet, and chocolate, scientists have found …