Girls V. Boys: Should It Matter?

Ariel Koren was elected the 2015 Class Board President at Penn University. Subsequently, Koren has found herself in the middle of a feminist heat storm because she made the comment that students should “stop worrying about the female leadership issues [within school politics] and do their own thing.”

The reason there was a “female leadership issue” at Penn was that when Koren was elected, she was identified as “female,” and not by her given name. “The female that won the competitive election,” as if that was so rare. The fact that a female could take charge in a competition and come out ahead, didn’t anyone tell Penn that females are strategy thinkers? We play to win.

The problem lies in the fact that some students think that to achieve gender equality we need to be more critical of the barriers to success that women face on campuses. Still others say that gender equality will be reached when there is no longer any need for front-page news to recognize the accomplishments of a woman as a leader simply because of her sex. For Koren to come out and say being female is not a big deal cuts both ways. It says to some that she is turning her back on feminism and to others it says she’s embracing that male or female the best person won.

Feminism is about women being seen as equals so is the best way to acknowledge that we do the same things as men (and some time beat them)? Or should we just act as if it’s not a big deal and this is the way the world works, sometimes you win sometimes you loose and what’s between your legs shouldn’t make a difference? There’s no clear cut road, but what is clear is it is a very long road ahead.

You Might Also Like ...

3 thoughts on “Girls V. Boys: Should It Matter?

  1. :-( The fact that the this is even being discussed depresses me. I look forward to a day when women are people too and not seen as something so different from our male counterparts.

  2. this is not an uncommon problem for oppressed groups. for example, in literature, authors who hail from minority groups struggle with labels such as “black writer,” “woman writer,” and of course, “black woman writer.” many minority authors have resented those labels, wishing to be identified simply as “American.” i don’t believe there is a correct answer. one major aspect of feminism for me is that women should all agree to our right to choose for ourselves (in whatever issue at hand) and should support each other in that (rather than all try to agree on one position which will, of course, never happen). so if Ariel Koren doesn’t want to be singled out for her femaleness, she has that perogative. And perhaps we have truly arrived if we have the courage to let her make that choice. Other women can still celebrate her accomplishment – and she remains the female winner for all to see, whether we make a big deal or not. btw – just found this blog – love what i see so far!

  3. Oh be still my beating heart. Such insight, such power in your words rochall. If only why all listened to you, the world would be such a better place for us all to live in. (/sarcasm, just in case it wasn’t obvious)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>